Furniture that offers both form and function is always a win in a home. Storage benches are popular pieces because they provide a place to sit and somewhere to keep items out of sight. But when choosing between an ottoman storage bench and a traditional storage bench, you might wonder: which one is better suited for my needs? In this article, we compare both kinds so you can decide what works best in your space, style, and budget.
What is an Ottoman Storage Bench?
An ottoman storage bench is a piece of furniture that combines these features:
- A cushioned top (often upholstered in fabric, leather or faux leather) that you can sit on or rest your feet.
- A hollow interior under that top, which lifts (via hinges or a removable lid) to reveal storage space.
- Often a softer, more padded appearance than traditional benches.
If you want to see examples, check out some of the ottoman storage benches here: ottoman storage benches collection.
What is a Traditional Storage Bench?
A traditional storage bench tends to have a simpler, more box-like design. It usually includes:
- A solid seat made of wood or bench slats, or a mix of wood and cushion (but less padding than ottomans).
- Storage space under the seat, sometimes with hinged lids, drop leaves, drawer compartments, or cubbies.
- Often more visible structure (legs, frame, maybe open shelving) rather than being fully enclosed or cushioned.
Traditional storage benches are often more rustic, classic, or functional in style.
Key Differences Between Ottoman and Traditional Storage Benches
Here are some of the main differences to help you decide:
| Feature | Ottoman Storage Bench | Traditional Storage Bench |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | Very comfortable. Padded top good for sitting or even putting feet up. | Less cushioned. More rigid seat. Better for short sitting or as a place to put things. |
| Style & Look | Softer, more luxurious. Upholstery adds warmth. Often blends into living room or bedroom decor. | More structured. Can be rustic, wooden, farmhouse, or more formal/traditional. |
| Storage Capacity | Since the whole top often lifts, you get a big empty space inside. Good for bulky items: blankets, pillows, toys. | Storage may be divided (drawers, shelves). Great for organized items like shoes, books, baskets. |
| Ease of Access | Lid or top flips up; sometimes you need both hands. Might have gas springs or hinges. | Drawers or open shelves are easier to access without lifting. Shelves allow seeing items quickly. |
| Durability & Maintenance | Upholstery may stain or wear over time; hinges need maintenance; soft materials need care. | Wood or solid surfaces are usually easier to clean; less risk of fabric damage. |
| Weight & Move-ability | Ottoman benches are often heavier because of padding and internal support. Harder to move often. | Traditional benches may be lighter, especially simple wooden ones. Easier to reposition. |
| Space Use | Good for hiding many items. Lid acts as large access point. But if lid opens upward, you need clearance above. | With drawers or shelves, you may need clearance in front; also bench height must allow access. |
Which One to Choose: Consider These Factors
Here are questions to ask yourself before choosing between the two:
- What will you store?
If you have large soft items—extra pillows, bedding, toys—an ottoman storage bench gives big, open space for them. If you want to store shoes, books, or smaller items that need dividing, a traditional bench with shelves or drawers may serve better. - Where will it go?
- Entryway or hall: Traditional benches might work better because you can drop shoes in open cubbies or lower shelves. Also, you often want hard surfaces to clean.
- Bedroom or living room: Ottomans shine here—they add comfort (you can sit, put feet up) and look cozier.
- How often do you need access?
If you need things often, a bench with drawers or open access will be easier than lifting a heavy lid every time. If it’s for seasonal items or things you don’t use daily, then an ottoman storage bench is fine. - Room size and height clearance
An ottoman’s lid needs clearance to open upward. If ceiling or shelf above is low, or space is tight, that could be an obstacle. Traditional benches often use front-facing drawers or open shelves that don’t need overhead space. - Style and décor preference
If your décor leans toward sleek lines, minimalism, rustic woods, or traditional craftsmanship, a traditional storage bench may match better. If you prefer a softer, plush, inviting look, or want furniture that doubles as extra seating, an ottoman can add warmth. - Cleaning and durability
Upholstered ottomans need more care: vacuuming, cleaning spills, perhaps re-upholstery eventually. Traditional wood or metal benches are easier to wipe or dust. Think about pets or kids, or how much wear and tear you expect.
Pros & Cons Summary
To help you see it all at a glance:
Ottoman Storage Bench
Pros:
- Very comfortable seating; can even act as a footrest.
- Generous hidden space; you can store bulky items.
- Adds softness and upholstery can enhance the room’s look.
Cons:
- Heavier; may be harder to move.
- Cleaning and maintaining upholstery can be more work.
- Need good lid mechanism; sometimes lids squeak or sag.
- Needs vertical clearance for opening.
Traditional Storage Bench
Pros:
- Easier to access items with drawers or open shelves.
- Usually more durable against spill, scratches, etc.
- Lightweight options exist; easier to move around.
- Variety in styles—wood, metal, rustic, formal—that can suit many décor themes.
Cons:
- Less comfortable to sit for long periods; less padding.
- Storage may be less spacious or divided, limiting what you store.
- Might look more utilitarian unless designed well.
How to Decide: Your Checklist
Here’s a short checklist you can use to make your decision:
- ____ Do I need soft seating in that space?
- ____ What items do I want to store? Bulky items or small sorted ones?
- ____ How frequently I will be opening storage? Daily or occasional?
- ____ Is there enough height above for an ottoman lid to open comfortably?
- ____ Do I have kids, pets, high traffic that may damage upholstery?
- ____ Which design style better matches my room: plush and cozy or structured and traditional?
- ____ What is my budget—not just for purchase but long-term maintenance?
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I use an ottoman storage bench instead of a coffee table?
Yes! Many people do. An ottoman bench can double as seating, a footrest, or a soft “coffee table” with a tray on top. Just be sure the surface is flat enough for placing items safely.
Q: Are ottoman benches more expensive?
Often, yes. Upholstery, padding, and good quality hinges add cost. Traditional benches made of simple wood or with minimal padding tend to cost less. But price varies greatly depending on materials and craftsmanship.
Q: Which one is more child-friendly?
Traditional benches with fewer soft surfaces may be easier to wipe clean. But ottomans with durable fabric or removable/washable covers can work too. Just look for rounded edges, safe hinges, and sturdy build.
Final Thoughts: Which One to Choose?
There’s no one “right” answer. It comes down to what you value most:
- If comfort, hiding a lot of soft clutter, and adding a cozy touch are top priorities, an ottoman storage bench is likely the better choice.
- If you want something practical, easy to access often, with minimal upkeep, then a traditional storage bench may suit you best.
You might even find a hybrid approach: a bench that has a cushioned top and some drawers or open shelves. That way you get a bit of both worlds.
In conclusion, think about how you use the space, what you want to store, and the level of comfort and style you prefer. Measure your room, test how much access you’ll need, and then choose the bench that makes your life easier and your home more beautiful.
Whether you go with an ottoman storage bench or a traditional one, good furniture can give you both storage and good looks. Make the one that fits you.
Clarksburg Commercial Landscaping: Expert Guide
Illuminate with Impact: Why Metal Table Lamps Shine in UK Homes
Everything You Need to Know About Professional Turf Installation in Croydon
Why Is Custom Steel Fabrication Becoming Increasingly Popular?
10 Reasons Why Tiny Homes Are Becoming More Popular
